A year-end pay stub and Form W-2 can show different wage totals because payroll gross pay and the W-2’s tax-specific wages measure different things. Match the employer, tax year and complete payroll history, then reconcile benefits, retirement deferrals, taxable noncash items and corrections. A different Box 1 amount alone does not prove an error.

Reviewed November 10, 2026 · U.S. year-end payroll reconciliation. The worked example uses fictional final 2025 records and the final 2025 W-2 instructions. Benefit exclusions and ordinary employee coverage are expressly assumed. This is not a completed return or a determination that a particular plan qualifies for an exclusion.

The last statement is a useful starting document, but its date and headings need context. A payroll correction, separate bonus payment or earlier system change may mean that one PDF does not show the full annual picture. Build a short explanation of the numbers rather than replacing one total with another.

For a missing issued form, use the former-employer W-2 retrieval guide. This article addresses a different task: checking records you already have.

Make sure both records describe the same scope

Check the legal employer, employee and printed tax year. A W-2 for one employer is not a summary of all jobs you held. A final pay stub from a new payroll platform may show transferred balances, only new-system activity or a separate reference to older records.

Use the payment calendar to identify the final relevant payroll run. A period ending in December may have a January payday; the period-end label alone does not establish the reporting year. Our pay period versus pay date guide explains that distinction.

List regular payrolls, separate bonus runs, manual payments and corrections. If the employer says the final annual totals include an adjustment not visible on the ordinary stub, ask for the supporting record. Do not assume that the PDF with the latest download timestamp is the last effective payroll record.

Compare wages with wages, and taxes with taxes

The final 2025 W-2 instructions distinguish federal reportable compensation in Box 1, the Box 3 Social Security wage amount and the Medicare wage total reported in Box 5. The related withholding amounts appear in different boxes. These are not three interchangeable labels for salary.

Match the annual field before testing a difference
W-2 fieldPayroll comparison to requestCommon wrong comparison
Box 1: wages, tips, other compensationFederal reportable wage reconciliation for that employer and yearAll cash gross pay without adjustments
Box 2: federal income tax withheldAnnual employee federal income-tax withholdingTotal taxes of every type
Box 3 and Box 4Social Security wages and employee tax, respectivelyMedicare wages or employer tax costs
Box 5 and Box 6Medicare wages and employee tax, respectivelyNet deposits or benefits paid by the employer
State/local wage and tax boxesThe jurisdiction-specific annual recordsAn assumption that every state wage amount equals federal Box 1

Check each field’s actual definition and relevant limits for the year. Different states can treat an item differently from federal rules, so a correct federal bridge should not be copied automatically into every state box. A complete explanation names the item, treatment and affected field.

Original example: $78,400 cash gross becomes $71,700 in Box 1

Assume a fictional ordinary employee has $78,400 of 2025 cash gross earnings. The employee paid $2,400 of qualifying health premiums through a valid arrangement assumed excluded from federal income-tax, Social Security and Medicare wages. Also assume $5,200 of traditional pretax 401(k) elective deferrals and an already valued $900 noncash fringe fully taxable for all three wage bases.

There are no other adjustments, tips, special coverage rules, repayments or payroll corrections in this illustration. Social Security wages are below the applicable 2025 annual ceiling. These facts are assumptions, not a conclusion about a reader’s benefits.

IRS Topic 424 explains why qualifying traditional elective deferrals can be omitted from federal Box 1 while remaining in Social Security and Medicare wages. The 2025 fringe-benefit guide addresses benefit exclusions and taxable values; eligibility and valuation must be established before using them in a real bridge.

Original fictional 2025 wage reconciliation
ItemFederal Box 1 effectBox 3/5 wage effect
Cash gross starting amount$78,400$78,400
Assumed qualifying health premiums−$2,400−$2,400
Traditional 401(k) deferrals−$5,200No reduction
Fully taxable noncash fringe+$900+$900
Resulting wage amount$71,700$76,900
Original fictional 2025 reconciliation: 78400 dollars cash gross, 71700 dollars W-2 Box 1 wages and 76900 dollars in both Social Security and Medicare wage boxes.
The fictional difference is explained by the specified wage treatments. No cash payment of the $900 noncash value is assumed.

The federal calculation is $78,400 − $2,400 − $5,200 + $900 = $71,700. The Social Security and Medicare wage calculation is $78,400 − $2,400 + $900 = $76,900. Their $5,200 difference matches the traditional deferral in this limited case.

Original wage adjustments are 2400 dollars qualified excluded health premiums, 5200 dollars traditional 401(k) deferrals and 900 dollars fully taxable noncash compensation.
The listed treatments are assumed valid for this ordinary employee. Real benefit arrangements, owners and special compensation can require different treatment.

A real statement might already include the taxable noncash value in a gross field. In that layout, adding it again would be wrong. Confirm what the starting total includes before applying any bridge. Our benefit-entry guide helps separate informational employer costs from taxable noncash compensation.

Reconcile withholding without inventing an income-tax rate

Suppose the fictional payroll record independently shows $7,800 of federal income tax withheld. That is the amount to reconcile to the corresponding employee withholding box, subject to actual corrections. It is not calculated by applying a made-up flat percentage to Box 1, and it is not the employee’s final annual income-tax liability.

Under the example’s ordinary 2025 coverage assumptions, $76,900 × 6.2% = $4,767.80 of employee Social Security tax and $76,900 × 1.45% = $1,115.05 of regular Medicare tax. There is no Additional Medicare Tax in this limited wage example. Actual payroll rounding and corrections should still be reviewed against the employer’s records.

Keep the employer’s matching contributions outside the employee withholding total. The FICA explanation shows why wage ceilings and separate components matter when checking a different year or earnings level.

Look for a concrete cause of any unexplained gap

First examine a separate run that was issued after the last ordinary check. Then check canceled or replaced checks, transferred opening balances, corrected benefit treatment and noncash adjustments. Do not assume that every difference represents another cash payment.

A reversal and replacement should be connected in the worksheet. A corrected statement is evidence of an update, not automatically a second set of wages. Preserve the original documents and identify which record supersedes which.

The year matters for repayments and corrections. Do not reverse a prior-year wage amount from current Box 1 simply because money was repaid during the current year. The signing-bonus repayment guide explains why same-year and later-year records need different treatment.

Our YTD gross-pay ledger guide provides a method for reconciling cumulative changes. The year-end task adds tax-specific wage definitions to that running-balance review.

Request the reconciliation before changing a return

Name the field, amount and expected bridge in your payroll question. For example: “My final payroll shows $78,400 cash gross. Please confirm the health-premium exclusion, traditional deferral and noncash adjustment used to reach $71,700 federal wages.” Include the tax year and relevant statement dates through the employer’s verified channel.

If a number appears incorrect, ask the employer whether an authorized correction is needed. Employees should not edit the employer-issued form to make it resemble a preferred total. Retain the explanation and any corrected form with the original record set.

A filing decision can depend on the actual error and current instructions. If a return has already been filed or the records remain inconsistent, obtain qualified assistance rather than guessing which figure to use. A screenshot or a calculator estimate does not resolve the missing facts.

A W-2 tool needs reconciled annual records

The Check Stubs Online W-2 tool prepares the supported edition from entered information. At review, its available year is 2025. Authorized employers should use actual annual wage and withholding totals and check the entire output.

It does not retrieve a former employer’s issued statement, resolve unexplained payroll differences or submit government filings merely by producing a PDF. Read the 2025 W-2 preparation guide for the separate document workflow. For a later year, verify the supported edition and that year’s final instructions first.

Year-end reconciliation questions

Should the final pay stub’s gross always equal W-2 Box 1?

No. Valid exclusions, deferrals and taxable noncash amounts can change the reportable wage base.

Does the last regular pay stub always contain every annual adjustment?

Not necessarily. Check separate payments, year-end adjustments and corrected records.

Can I add every W-2 box to find annual income?

No. Several boxes describe overlapping wage bases, tax amounts or informational items.

Can I use this fictional bridge for an S corporation owner or special benefit arrangement?

No. Its ordinary employee and benefit assumptions are explicit; different facts require separate treatment.

The Check Stubs Online Editorial Team reviewed final 2025 wage-reporting materials and the currently supported tool, and independently checked the original wage and employee-tax reconciliation.